Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

Winner
The GE Profile Opal 2.0 XL is a solid choice if you're after nugget-style ice that’s soft and chewable, ideal for drinks that benefit from ice that cools without watering down quickly. It can produce up to 38 pounds of ice in 24 hours, which means it’s capable of serving a party or regular household use comfortably. The 3-pound storage drawer holds a decent amount of ice ready to use, which is good for convenience but may require frequent emptying during heavy use.
One standout feature is its 1-gallon water tank that removes the need for hooking up to a water line, making it pretty portable for a countertop appliance of this size — though at about 17.5 by 13.4 by 16.5 inches and 38 pounds, it’s not something you’d want to move daily. It’s fairly fast, delivering the first batch in about 10 minutes, so you won’t be waiting long for ice. The built-in WiFi and smart app integration allow you to monitor and control the ice maker remotely, which adds a modern convenience, especially if you enjoy tech features and voice commands via Alexa or Google.
Maintenance is straightforward thanks to a cleaning system designed to keep the ice fresh; water filters and cleaning supplies are available separately, which is typical for appliances of this type. Noise levels during ice production are moderate, similar to comparable machines. If you want a stylish, black stainless steel machine that combines good ice quality, decent production speed, and smart controls, this model meets those needs while offering moderate storage capacity and manageable cleaning requirements.
The Frigidaire Nugget Ice Maker is a solid choice if you're after soft, chewable nugget-style ice similar to what you get at restaurants. It produces a generous amount of ice—up to 44 pounds per day—which is plenty for small gatherings or daily use. You don't need to hook it up to a water line; just fill the reservoir manually, making it convenient for most countertops. The ice storage basket holds about 3 pounds, so while it can make a lot of ice quickly, you may need to use or clear ice frequently during heavy use.
The unit is compact enough to fit under most cabinets, and its sleek cream finish with a viewing window adds a nice touch to your kitchen. Its cycle time is about 10-15 minutes for the first batch, which is fairly quick. The touch control panel is intuitive to use, and the automatic self-cleaning function helps keep the machine fresh with minimal effort. Models like this typically produce some sound during ice making, so expect some background noise. At 30.8 pounds, it is somewhat portable but still a bit heavy to move often.
The machine also includes practical extras like an ice scoop and drip tray. This ice maker is best suited for home users who want easy access to nugget ice with a good daily production rate and low maintenance, though the smaller storage capacity means it’s not ideal if you want to stockpile large amounts of ice at once.
The Kismile Nugget Ice Makers Countertop model is a solid choice if you want quick and easy access to chewable nugget-style ice at home. It produces up to 35 pounds of ice per day, which is a good amount for household use or small gatherings. You’ll get your first batch ready in just 7 minutes, so it’s quite efficient. The ice is soft and chewy, great for drinks like cocktails or sodas because it melts slowly and keeps flavors pure. The machine has a moderate ice storage capacity visible through a clear top, making it easy to see when you need more ice. Refilling water is simple with a 1.1-liter tank, though this size means you might refill it a few times during heavy use.
Cleaning is hassle-free thanks to a one-touch self-cleaning function that takes about 15 minutes, which is helpful for keeping the machine fresh without much effort. Size-wise, it’s compact and stylish enough for most countertops and weighs about 22 pounds, so it’s portable but not super lightweight. Noise levels are low at about 43 decibels, letting you run it without much disturbance. On the downside, the ice storage isn’t very large, so it’s less suited for big parties, and the water tank capacity limits continuous ice production before refilling. Also, while nugget ice is great for texture, it may not suit everyone’s preferences if you want traditional cube shapes.
This model is ideal for users looking for a fast, easy-to-use countertop ice maker that produces soft nugget ice quietly and with minimal maintenance.